Awards To Honor the Life and Legacy of
EDWIN C. BEARSS
It was very sad to hear in 2020 that Ed Bearss -- legendary Civil War historian and lifetime member of our Round Table -- had passed away. We miss him dearly. Ed showed many of us literally what it meant to have our "boots on the ground" at a battlefield, and we will remember him and that phrase every time we take a battlefield tour from here on out.
And it is fitting that we seek to celebrate his legacy and his contributions to the study of Civil War history on a continuing basis for many years and many generations to come. Ed was an honorary lifetime member of the CWRTDC, spoke regularly at our meetings, and guided many of our tours.
In appreciation of Ed’s dedication to battlefield preservation, the CWRTDC had for years made an annual donation to a historic site selected by Ed. See complete history below. In 2021, the Board of Directors unanimously decided to broaden the Preservation Award to a Civil War-related site selected by the Board and to increase the amount of donation using a newly created fund supported by individual contributions by members and other admirers of Ed. Monetary gifts to support future CWRTDC awards in honor of Ed’s life and legacy can be submitted using the PayPal module below.
Last year, the CWRTDC awarded the Preservation Award to the African American Civil War Museum, and the recipient of the Legacy Award to Ms. Wendy Swanson. A post about those awards is available at https://cwrtdc-calendar.blogspot.com/2022/06/bearss-awards.html
On February 8, 2023, via Zoom, the Round Table will present this year's awards to honor the extraordinary life and legacy of Civil War historian Edwin Cole Bearss. The recipient of the “CWRTDC Edwin C. Bearss Preservation Award” is the Battle of New Market Heights Memorial and Education Association (BNMHMEA), and the recipient of the “CWRTDC Edwin C. Bears Legacy Award” is Mr. Burrus "Buzz" Carnahan.
The ceremony will be followed by a presentation from Jon Meacham entitled “A Sacred Effort: Lincoln's American Theology." Mr. Meacham notes that Lincoln tends to be seen as the greatest of American presidents—a remote icon—or as a politician driven more by calculation than by conviction. He will paint a portrait of a very human Lincoln—an imperfect man whose moral antislavery commitment, essential to the story of justice in America, began as he grew up in an antislavery Baptist community; who insisted that slavery was a moral evil; and who sought, as he put it, to do right as God gave him to see the right.
Information about the dinner and Mr. Meacham's presentation is available at https://cwrtdc-meetings.blogspot.com/p/jmeacham.html
The recipient of the Preservation Award is the Battle of New Market Heights Memorial and Education Association (https://battleofnewmarketheights.org/). The BNMHMEA is a non-profit 501(c)(3) entity, whose mission is to commemorate and educate. It seeks to erect a historical monument at the site of the Battle of New Market Heights honoring the United States Colored Troops who served in the Third Division of the XVIII Corps (Army of the James). Among these men were fourteen African American soldiers and two white officers who received the Medal of Honor for acts of heroism on September 29, 1864. The BNMHMEA also seeks to educate the public about this significant military victory by the United States Colored Troops.
Edwin C. Bearss Legacy Award
The Board also approved the creation of an annual Legacy Award, which is non-monetary, to be given to persons who exemplify and emulate Ed’s mission through their own efforts to preserve U.S. Civil War historic sites, landmarks, and education.
The CWRTDC is pleased to announce that the recipient of the Legacy Award is Mr. Burrus “Buzz” Carnahan, a resident of Vienna, VA, until his passing last September. See https://cwrtdc-newsletters.blogspot.com/p/in-memoriam.html
Mr. Carnahan served our Nation, for 20 years as an Air Force Judge Advocate, specializing in international law, and for 17 years as a Foreign Affairs Officer at the State Department in the Office of Nuclear Energy, specializing in nuclear energy, safety and security. As a Senior Analyst at SAIC for 11 years, Mr Carnahan focused on arms control and nonproliferation. He also taught a course entitled "Law of War" for 25 years as a Professorial Lecturer at the George Washington School of Law.
On the Civil War, he wrote two books: Act of Justice: Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation and the Law of War (2007) and Lincoln on Trial: Southern Civilians and the Law of War (2010).
Over the years, several organizations invited Mr. Carnahan to talk to them about Lincoln and his era. At a National Archives symposium in 2010 (“The Civil War: Fresh Perspectives”) and at one in 2011 (“The Latest in Lincoln Scholarship”), Mr. Carnahan discussed Lincoln and his era. And, for the Lincoln Cottage, at the Soldier’s Home in DC, he talked about the Emancipation Proclamation at one of its first “Cottage Conversations.”
Mr. Carnahan was a past president of the Lincoln Group of the District of Columbia (www.lincolnian.org), spoke to the Group, and regularly participated in its book study forum. He was also a member of the CWRTDC and made presentations on Lincoln at its meetings. Recordings of Mr. Carnahan's presentations to the CWRTDC are available at https://cwrtdc-audio.blogspot.com/p/carnahan-zoom.html and https://cwrtdc-audio.blogspot.com/p/carnahan-audio.html
In Gettysburg, Mr. Carnahan joined the Lincoln Forum and served on its Advisory Board. In Fairfax, VA, he was a speaker and a docent at the “Historic Blenheim and the Civil War Interpretative Center” (https://www.fairfaxva.gov/government/historic-resources/historic-blenheim). This site is on the Northern Virginia Graffiti Trail and consists of a c.1859 brick farm house and grounds where Union soldiers were encamped during part of the Civil War. Mr. Carnahan greatly enjoyed talking to visitors about the background of the soldiers who stayed on the property. He was a valued docent because of his extensive knowledge that provided context for the individual stories of each soldier that wrote or drew on the walls of the farmhouse.
In addition, for Cultural Tourism DC, Mr. Carnahan developed a walking tour, “Lincoln and the Civil War in Foggy Bottom.” He was also the author of A Guide to Lincoln Sites In and Around Washington, DC, a pamphlet he published in 2009 for the Lincoln Group of DC. These two projects underscore his love of teaching and educating.
_____________________________________________
The CWRTDC will present the awards during an in-person/hybrid meeting. Information about the dinner and Mr. Meacham's presentation is available at https://cwrtdc-meetings.blogspot.com/p/jmeacham.html
Or dial in by your location:
+1 301 715 8592 US (Washington DC)
+1 312 626 6799 US (Chicago)
+1 669 900 9128 US (San Jose)
Meeting ID: 828 9304 8523
Passcode: 24641769
Find your local number: https://us02web.zoom.
For a cheat sheet on how to use Zoom's control features click HERE
The event is free to attend and all are welcome! Additional details about the ceremony are posted on the CWRTDC’s website at www.cwrtdc.org. More information about Ed Bearss and the awards is posted at https://cwrtdc-calendar.blogspot.com.
A copy of the News Release for the awards ceremony is available HERE (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ypqMpmEKwu0Ff-UuK_2rCRV7xIXYsAMb/view)
_____________________________________________
Copied below is a post about Ed written by our former President and current Director Susan Claffey.
(1923-2020)
We've received the sad news that legendary Civil War Historian and Lifetime member of our Round Table Ed Bearss has passed away. Ed was 97 years old.
Edwin Cole Bearss was born in Billings, Montana, on June 26, 1923. He grew up on his grandfather's ranch near Hardin, Montana, in the shadow of the Rosebud Mountains and within a bike ride of the Little Bighorn Battlefield. In Ed's own words,
I was interested in history from the time I was in the second grade. At that time, I was interested in Lewis and Clark and the Nez Perce, because I grew up in Montana. I became interested in the Civil War in the seventh grade. My father liked to read to my brother and me books that he was interested in. He did not read children’s books. Someone had given him a book by John Thomason on Jeb Stuart. My father read this book to me, and that captured me—I’ve been interested in the Civil War since then.
That interest was reflected by the fact that on the ranch, the E Bar S, he started naming the cattle for Civil War generals and battles. He often said his favorite milk cow was Antietam.
He attended a one-room school in Sarpy, Montana and in 1937 was sent to St. John's Military Academy in Delafield, Wisconsin. He graduated from Hardin High School and, with World War II underway, he immediately joined the Marine Corps (Ed's family has a long history with the Marines, his father, Omar, served in World War I. His father’s cousin Hiram I. Bearss, a famous Marine colonel nicknamed “Hiking Hiram,” fought in France during World War I and received the Medal of Honor for service in the Philippines in 1901. Ed’s daughter and grandson also served in the Corps).
He served with the 3rd Marine Raider Battalion and 1st Marine Division. In the invasion of Guadalcanal and New Britain, Ed was seriously wounded by machine gun fire. He spent 26 months in various hospitals for multiple surgeries, bone grafts, and rehabilitation. In fact, it was only a couple of years ago that Ed was treated at a VA hospital during a trip to Johnstown, PA for a piece of bone fragment that worked its way to the surface after 75 years. He got quite a kick out of telling that story.
After the war, he took advantage of the GI bill to study at Georgetown University, receiving a bachelor's degree in Foreign Service in 1949. He took a job with the Navy Hydrographic Office in Suitland, MD, where he stayed for 3 years. He then attended Indiana University and graduated with his M.A. in history, writing his thesis on Patrick Cleburne.
Ed’s career with the National Park Service got its start in 1955, when he was stationed at Vicksburg, Mississippi as a Park Historian. While there, he did the research leading him and two friends to the long lost resting place of the Union gunboat Cairo and he was instrumental in its rise from the bottom of the Yazoo River. He also located two forgotten forts at Grand Gulf, Mississippi and helped get Grand Gulf named a Mississippi State Military Monument. He was the founder of the Mississippi Civil War Round Table in 1956, which later consolidated with the Jackson Civil War Round Table.
In 1966, Ed was transferred to Washington, DC. He rose to prominence and became the Chief Historian in November 1981, a position he held until July 1994. Then he served as the Director's Special Assistant for Military Sites until his retirement on October 1, 1995. But Ed never really retired; through lectures, television, writing, and as a renowned battlefield guide, he continued his association with our nation's military history. He spoke to our Round Table and many other round tables many, many times. He also served as our guide for more field trips and day tours than can be counted. His final field trip for us was the 2013 trip to Vicksburg. He last spoke to us in September 2019 on the discovery and raising of the Cairo.
Ed received numerous awards in the field of history and preservation: the T. Harry Williams Award; the Bruce Catton Award; the Alvin Calman Award; the Bell I. Wiley Award and others. He was chosen Man of the Year at Vicksburg in 1963. He received the Harry S. Truman Award for Meritorious Service in the field of Civil War History. In 1964 he was chosen to become a member of the Company of Military Historians and was voted a Fellow in that organization. In 1983 he won the Department of the Interior's Distinguished Service Award, the highest award given by the department. He received a commendation from the Secretary of the Army in 1985. He is a veteran of 50 years of Government Service.
He has done detailed studies for the National Park Service for many areas: Vicksburg; Pea Ridge; Wilson's Creek; the Ray House; Fort Smith; Stones River; Fort Donelson; Battles around Richmond; Bighorn Canyon; Eisenhower Farm; the gold miners' route over Chilkoot Pass; LBJ Ranch; Fort Moultrie; Fort Point; William Howard Taft House; Fort Hancock; Boston Navy Yard; Herbert Hoover National Historic Site and others. He was instrumental in the establishment of Monocacy National Battlefield. In 1990, he was featured as a commentator on the PBS program The Civil War, which as of this writing is the most popular program ever to be broadcast by that network. More recently, he has appeared on the Arts & Entertainment Channel's Civil War Journal.
Ed was a force of nature and always at his best “on the ground” of a battlefield. Those of us who were privileged enough to see him in “full sway,” with eyes closed and voice booming, will never forget. He made history come alive and truly was its “Pied Piper.” We won’t see the likes of his amazing charismatic personality again.
Thank you, Ed. Thank you for your service. Thank you for your knowledge. And thank you for sharing it so willingly. May you rest in peace.
Author: Susan K Claffey
Photo: https://kcwrtorg.wordpress.com/2016/10/31/ed-bearss-returns-to-knoxville-nov-14/
_________________
History of the CWRTDC’s Edwin C. Bearss Award
The December 2003 Newsletter of the Civil War Round Table of the District of Columbia announced that the Board had established a $1000 donation to a Civil War preservation cause to honor Edwin C. Bearss' extensive contributions to Civil War historical research, preservation, and interest. The recipient of the donation would be chosen by the Board and would be based on recommendations from Ed Bearss. See https://drive.google.com/file/d/1a1yp4t4j6uP43T_BYulnEk--1dSUqb87/view
Also added to the dinner reservation form used at the time was a line that read “Contribution to Edwin C. Bearss Award.” In addition, members attending the dinners could contribute spare change and bills to a collection jar shaped like a bear: a big plastic Bear(ss) jar.
This effort was promoted and coordinated principally by Susan Claffey, former President and current Director of the CWRTDC. Thank you, Susan!
The donation was often awarded in conjunction with an annual party that Wendy Swanson (also a former President and Director of CWRTDC) and the “Bearss Brigade” organized and sponsored not only to celebrate Ed’s birthday, but also -- per Ed’s wishes – to collect donations from many other organizations and friends to support a recipient of Ed’s choosing. Wendy and the Bearss Brigade often collected over $10,000 in donations at those parties! Thank you, Wendy!
Now that Ed is no longer with us, the Board decided to enhance the Ed Bearss Award so as to continue to honor Ed and his legacy, as described above. Ed’s friends miss him dearly, and it is fitting to see what the CWRTDC can do to expand the award that celebrates his legacy and his contributions to CW history on a continuing basis for many years to come.
The recipients to date of the CWRTDC’s Edwin C. Bearss Awards are listed below:
Year Amount Recipient
2004 1,000.00 Civil War Preservation Trust – for Fort Donelson
2005 1,000.00 Gettysburg Battlefield Preservation Association – Daniel Lady Farm
2006 1,000.00 Friends of Chickamauga & Chattanooga
2007 1,000.00 Civil War Trust - for White Oak Road, Bentonville, and Shiloh
2008 1,000.00 Monocacy National Battlefield
2009 1,000.00 Civil War Preservation Trust - for Port Republic
2010 1,000.00 Richmond Battlefield Association
2011 1,000.00 Civil War Trust - for Shiloh National Military Park
2012 1,000.00 Civil War Trust - for Franklin
2013 1,000.00 Friends of Raymond Battlefield
2014 1,000.00 Franklin's Charge
2015 1,000.00 Friends of Raymond Battlefield
2016 1,000.00 Shenandoah Valley Battlefields Foundation
2017 1,000.00 Gettysburg Foundation
2018 1,000.00 Appomattox Court House National Historical Park
2019 1,000.00 Friends of Vicksburg National Military Park
2020 1,000.00 Grand Gulf Military Park
2021 2,500.00 African American Civil War Museum (Preservation Award)
2021 N/A Ms. Wendy Swanson (Legacy Award)
2022 2,500.00 Battle of New Market Heights Mem. & Edu. Assoc. (Preservation Award)
2022 N/A Mr. Burrus Carnahan (Legacy Award)
TOTAL $22,000
For information about the the history of other awards given by the CWRTDC, click HERE or visit https://drive.google.com/file/d/1KDif1-SImVUQotFjYJHCnM-SYYKrDVzq/view
